I am not a big re-reader of books. In fact, I hardly ever re-read any book. But, a couple of weeks ago I decided to re-read Gone With the Wind since it has been probably 10 years since I read it last. I was a huge fan then, and again I am convinced it is one of the best books EVER. I am already a historical fiction fan anyway, but this book is in a class of it’s own. It's no wonder it won the Pulitzer Prize.
I love the historical and cultural aspects of it, but what I really love is the characters. There are very few books that can develop a character to the point that you know all their flaws and inner workings, yet you are still deeply intrigued by them, admire them and yet are repulsed by them at the same time. There are few books that can develop its protagonists in such a way that they could easily be the antagonists, have them do things that morally you would object to, and yet, somehow you are still able to completely relate to them and also believe that the end justifies the means. I mean, how can you not love a dainty Southern belle who is ballsy enough to blow the face off of an intruder, marry men she doesn't love, and grate against the status quo in order to protect her family and get what she wants?
And I love the love/hate relationship between Scarlett and Rhett Butler. It gives you some of the most classic diaglogue of all time. The lack of sappiness and knight-in-shining-armor crap (although he is her knight in shining armor) that is usually in romances is replaced with the shrewdness of their characters and the utter rawness of their relationship as it develops over the years. They see each other for what they truly are (which isn’t always pretty), they say it like it is, and they have some dang hot chemistry, too. Ultimately, I think this novel could be considered a tragedy, but the grit and the gumption that permeates the entire book doesn't let you feel that it is.
Another plus with this story is that there are very few books that translate over into films that capture the core of the book so honestly. Gone With the Wind the movie is, out of necessity, a thinner version of the book, but I think overall it portrays the story and characters as they are in the book, which is why it is also such a great movie. My main pet peave with the movie is I think they make Ashley way too wimpy, when he should have come across as gentlemanly, handsome, and scholarly. The book is obviously more detailed and contains things the movie leaves out (like Scarlett having children by her first two husbands, for example, and some of the characters) and I think the book is a little less innocent than the movie, but overall it is a good adaptation. I don't think you get as much of the inner workings of the characters' minds in the movie, which to me is of huge interest in the book, but it is still a great movie and if you are not interested in reading a 1500 page book then I recommend at least seeing the movie so you don't miss out on the story.
To be honest, I have no idea where I am going with this or even why I am writing it. I guess to say that if you want something a little more meaty to read with lots of grit, drama, romance, and unflinching honesty, then I highly recommend this book.
I love the historical and cultural aspects of it, but what I really love is the characters. There are very few books that can develop a character to the point that you know all their flaws and inner workings, yet you are still deeply intrigued by them, admire them and yet are repulsed by them at the same time. There are few books that can develop its protagonists in such a way that they could easily be the antagonists, have them do things that morally you would object to, and yet, somehow you are still able to completely relate to them and also believe that the end justifies the means. I mean, how can you not love a dainty Southern belle who is ballsy enough to blow the face off of an intruder, marry men she doesn't love, and grate against the status quo in order to protect her family and get what she wants?
And I love the love/hate relationship between Scarlett and Rhett Butler. It gives you some of the most classic diaglogue of all time. The lack of sappiness and knight-in-shining-armor crap (although he is her knight in shining armor) that is usually in romances is replaced with the shrewdness of their characters and the utter rawness of their relationship as it develops over the years. They see each other for what they truly are (which isn’t always pretty), they say it like it is, and they have some dang hot chemistry, too. Ultimately, I think this novel could be considered a tragedy, but the grit and the gumption that permeates the entire book doesn't let you feel that it is.
Another plus with this story is that there are very few books that translate over into films that capture the core of the book so honestly. Gone With the Wind the movie is, out of necessity, a thinner version of the book, but I think overall it portrays the story and characters as they are in the book, which is why it is also such a great movie. My main pet peave with the movie is I think they make Ashley way too wimpy, when he should have come across as gentlemanly, handsome, and scholarly. The book is obviously more detailed and contains things the movie leaves out (like Scarlett having children by her first two husbands, for example, and some of the characters) and I think the book is a little less innocent than the movie, but overall it is a good adaptation. I don't think you get as much of the inner workings of the characters' minds in the movie, which to me is of huge interest in the book, but it is still a great movie and if you are not interested in reading a 1500 page book then I recommend at least seeing the movie so you don't miss out on the story.
To be honest, I have no idea where I am going with this or even why I am writing it. I guess to say that if you want something a little more meaty to read with lots of grit, drama, romance, and unflinching honesty, then I highly recommend this book.
7 comments:
Never heard of it.
You make me want to read it again soon. I think it's probably been about 10 years for me, too!
That is my ALL TIME favorite movie! Have you read Rhett Butler's People yet? My mom couldn't put it down. Its the story of his life/family before he met Scarlett. Its written by Donald McCaig. :-)
I've never read it, but I remember you loving it. I may have to read it... sometime...
Oh please please please write a big hormonal post! I've been thinking this whole time that Tara never whines like I do and I really want to hear. DO IT!!!! It will make me feel better :D
And I've never read the book, but always loved the movie. I read the "sequel" written by whoever it was and it was terrible.
I have not read the book. I need to because I loved the movie. I will have to put it on my list.
Frankly my dear...I think you are right.
CWH
Post a Comment